The story of Deland McCullough and Sherman Smith is a remarkable tale of fate, discovery, and reconciliation. It begins in 1972 when McCullough was placed for adoption by his biological mother, Carol Briggs, after a brief relationship with Smith, who was unaware of the pregnancy. McCullough was adopted by Adelle Comer and A.C. McCullough in Youngstown, Ohio. Despite growing up without his biological father, McCullough found solace in sports, particularly football, which eventually led him to a successful college and professional career.
McCullough’s journey took a significant turn when he pursued the unsealing of his adoption records in the 2010s, leading him to discover his biological parents. This revelation was particularly profound because Smith, who had mentored McCullough during his college years at Miami (Ohio) and maintained a close relationship with him, turned out to be his biological father. The bond they had shared unknowingly as coach and mentee was deepened by the newfound family connection.
Both men navigated the emotional complexities of their situation with grace and understanding. Smith expressed regret for the circumstances that led to McCullough’s adoption, but both agreed to focus on building their relationship from that point forward. Their story emphasizes the power of forgiveness, the importance of mentorship, and the unexpected ways in which lives can intertwine.
McCullough’s experiences and the surprising connection with Smith have been shared in his book “Runs in the Family” and inspired a film, “Show Me the Father,” underscoring the themes of fatherhood and belonging. Their journey together highlights the enduring impact of relationships and the resilience required to overcome life’s unexpected challenges.