Thanksgiving is a time for gratitude, family gatherings, and feasting — but let’s be honest, it’s often the pie that steals the spotlight at the holiday table. Whether your tradition calls for classic pumpkin, traditional apple, or you dream of something a little more adventurous like peach, blueberry, or dark chocolate pecan, Holland’s local bakeries and pie shops have you covered.
If you’re still searching for the ultimate Thanksgiving pie, here’s a round-up of some top spots around Holland, featuring standout flavors and important pre-order deadlines to make your holiday meal truly memorable.
Crane’s Pie Pantry
A perennial favorite, Crane’s Pie Pantry in Fennville was named the region’s best local pie spot earlier this year — and it’s easy to see why. Crusts are flaky, fillings are generous, and the variety is impressive. Their Thanksgiving menu includes classics like pumpkin, apple, and cherry, as well as tempting options like peach and dark chocolate pecan. Orders can be placed online at [cranespiepantry.com/order-a-pick-up](https://cranespiepantry.com/order-a-pick-up), by phone at 269-561-2297, or in person at 6054 124th Ave. Be sure to reserve your pie by Nov. 23 for a pick-up the week of Thanksgiving.
Russ’ Restaurant
This locally beloved restaurant is making pie dreams come true by accepting pre-orders through Nov. 25 at its various locations around Holland. Pumpkin, apple, coconut cream, peanut butter, and pecan are just a few of the flavors up for grabs — and if you’re wondering which to try, you’re not alone; Russ’ pies are getting rave reviews. Place your order for pick-up on Nov. 26 via [russrestaurants.com/pie-reservation](https://russrestaurants.com/pie-reservation).
Bowerman’s on Eighth
At Bowerman’s on Eighth (2 E. Eighth St.), expect vibrant fruit-forward flavors, including blueberry, cherry blueberry, peach blueberry, and harvest moon — alongside classics pumpkin, pecan, and caramel apple. Pies and other desserts are available for pre-order until Nov. 23 at [bowermans-on-8th.square.site](https://bowermans-on-8th.square.site), with pick-up scheduled for Nov. 25-26.
Crane’s in the City
If you love Crane’s pies but want a more downtown Holland experience, Crane’s in the City at 11 E. Eighth St. is a great bet. Pre-orders for Thanksgiving pies are open online at [cranesinthecity.com/orderform](https://cranesinthecity.com/orderform) for a pick-up on Nov. 25-26. With flavors ranging from the fruity (apple, blueberry, cherry, rhubarb raspberry) to the indulgent (chocolate pecan, berry crisps, cheese strudels), you’ll find something for every guest.
Bliss Bakery
For those seeking gluten-free options (or just something a little different), Bliss Bakery at 102 S. River Ave. offers sugar-free pumpkin pie, apple streusel, and a decadent pecan pie made with chocolate chips and bourbon. According to their [Facebook page](https://facebook.com/blissbakerymi), Thanksgiving pre-orders are accepted through Nov. 14, so act fast.
A Slice for Everyone
No matter which direction your pie cravings take you — flaky fruit pies, rich chocolate pecan, or allergy-friendly treats — Holland’s local businesses are ready to help you set the stage for a flawless Thanksgiving dessert spread. Just be sure to check those pre-order deadlines. After all, nothing says celebration quite like a slice of homemade pie shared among family and friends.
Happy feasting — and happy Thanksgiving!
Aaron Bowman/The Right Vibe
